About the 音MADと見做されうる動画 tag
Linked entities: /user/SnO2WMaN, /tag/音madと見做されうる動画
I wanted to ask why did you create this tag? I understand that this tag is meant for videos that are not traditionally considered as otoMADs but could be considered as such given their use of techniques or context.
While I agree there are certainly works out there that would fall under this category, I think this tag is a little too subjective in my opinion. At what point does a work become too non-traditional to qualify? What would make a work traditionally considered as an otoMAD, and thus not qualify for this tag? I would like to know if you have any criteria for this tag please.
I do not have a problem with any of the works with this tag; I think they all are valid entries to otoDB and are otoMADs in a way. I am just curious about the reasoning behind making this a tag. If this tag should stay, I think it should be clear when this tag is applicable to a work at least.
Currently, this tag is applied exclusively to commercial content, such as promotional videos produced by companies or footage taken from television programs.
There is a similar tag, "Official otoMAD," and one criterion for distinguishing between them could be whether the party releasing the content explicitly identifies it as a otoMAD.
As for whether it is actually necessary to make such a distinction, I find it difficult to say.